Gas vs Wood: A Battle of the Braais

The braai, as quintessentially South African as the Table Mountain or a Kruger sunset, is more than just about cooking food; it’s about tradition, history, and camaraderie.

Central to this practice is the often debated choice of fuel: gas or wood. This decision goes beyond merely lighting a flame; it’s about the tales we tell, the memories we create, and our footprint on the environment.


Historical Roots: The Evolution of the Braai

Historically, indigenous communities of South Africa used open flames as a means of sustenance, invariably relying on wood as their primary fuel. As the nation progressed, the advent of gas brought a contemporary twist to this ancient ritual. The simmering debate began, does the convenience of modernity compromise the authenticity of tradition?

  1. Efficiency: The Quick Flame vs The Patient Ember

Gas Braais: Gas braais stand as a testament to modern convenience. They ignite with ease, offering a rapid, consistent heat that promises a meal in a matter of minutes. It’s an ode to the age we live in, where efficiency is paramount. The ability to have an impromptu gathering and have your braai ready at a moment’s notice makes gas a popular choice among those with a fast-paced lifestyle. Furthermore, the precise temperature control offered by gas ensures each cut of meat is cooked uniformly, reducing chances of over or under-cooking.

Wood Braais: In contrast, wood braais are about patience and process. The very act of choosing the right kind of wood, building the fire, and waiting for the embers to glow the right shade of orange is a ritual in itself. It’s a labour of love, where the time invested in the preparation becomes an integral part of the braaiing experience. And while it might seem cumbersome to some, for many, the slow dance of flames and the warmth of the coals are essential to the charm of a wood-fired braai.

  1. Flavour: The Essence of the Feast

Gas Braais: When it comes to gas, what you’re getting is a clean, unaltered taste. The flavours of the meat, marinades, and spices remain unmasked, presenting a purity in every bite. High-end gas braais, in their quest to replicate the authentic braai experience, incorporate features like flavour bars and lava rocks. These elements aim to infuse a smoky nuance to the dishes, reminiscent of wood fires.

Wood Braais: The wood braai, however, is all about that deep, smoky infusion. Each variety of wood, be it the sweet undertones of applewood or the robust character of oak, adds a unique layer of flavour to the food. It’s akin to a gourmet experience, where every morsel offers a tale of the forest and fire.

  1. Maintenance: The After-Feast Chore

Gas Braais: One of the notable advantages of gas is the ease of cleanup. Absent of ash and soot, gas braais typically require a simple wipe-down and occasional deep clean. However, it’s crucial to keep an eye on the gas connections, hoses, and burners to ensure safety. Over time, consistent performance requires periodic servicing.

Wood Braais: The aftermath of a wood braai is a more involved affair. The ash residue demands careful cleaning, and the grates, exposed to intense heat and food residue, require regular maintenance. Additionally, sourcing and storing quality wood, ensuring it remains dry and ready for use, is a constant task in the wood braai narrative.

  1. Environmental Considerations: Mother Earth’s Stake

Gas Braais: From an ecological standpoint, gas is cleaner. Its combustion results in fewer pollutants entering the atmosphere. But, it’s essential to consider the environmental impact of gas production and distribution, often involving significant energy consumption and emissions.

Wood Braais: Wood, if viewed in isolation, presents a cyclical carbon footprint. Trees absorb carbon dioxide during their lifetime, and burning them simply releases this back. However, the equation becomes more complex when factoring in deforestation and the importance of using sustainably sourced wood.


Economic Implications: Pockets & Pennies


Gas Braais: Though a gas braai might command a steeper initial price, its running costs tend to be consistent, revolving around periodic gas refills. Given their design for durability and convenience, many modern gas braais promise longevity, ensuring a return on investment over the years.

Wood Braais: While the initial setup might be less taxing on the pocket, the recurring costs of wood, especially if one is particular about wood types and quality, can add up. Additionally, wear and tear from intense heat and exposure might necessitate replacements or repairs over time.

Choosing between gas and wood is an intimate decision, rooted in personal experiences, lifestyle choices, and values. Perhaps the focus should be less on the ‘better’ fuel and more on the quality of the braai itself, ensuring it caters to the individual’s needs and preferences.

In the end, every braai, regardless of its fuel, is a celebration of culture, community, and culinary delight.

Share this page

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Product Enquiry

Please provide full detail in the form below for us to best assist you. Complete physical address including city/town.